Drag-along and tag-along rights provisions are frequently incorporated in a company’s shareholders’ agreement or articles of association. They are designed to safeguard the interests of majority and minority shareholders in the event of a company sale.
This article explains the key legal differences between these rights and outlines the main points to consider when negotiating such provisions.
Drag-Along Rights – What Are They?
Drag-along rights, also referred to as ‘come along’ or ‘bring along’ rights, allow a majority shareholder to compel a minority shareholder to join in and sell their company shares when a sale occurs.
This means that minority shareholders not involved in the sale cannot obstruct the sale of a company that has already received approval by the majority shareholder or a collective majority of existing shareholders and are effectively ‘dragged along’ on the sale.
For majority shareholders, the primary benefit of drag-along rights is the enhancement of the business’s marketability, as buyers typically seek complete control of a company. By establishing drag-along rights, the majority shareholder can ensure that 100% of the share capital of a company is available to a third-party buyer.
It is important to note that the majority owner must offer the minority shareholder the same price, terms and conditions for their shares as those provided to any other seller.
What to Consider When Negotiating Drag Along Right Provisions
Some of the important issues to consider when drafting and negotiating drag-along provisions include the following:
Threshold Percentage
This refers to the percentage necessary to activate drag-along rights, which is usually set around 75%. However, this figure may be adjusted based on the bargaining power and structure of the involved parties.
Pre-Emptive Rights
In instances where the agreement does not clarify the relationship between the drag-along rights and pre-emptive rights (which allows shareholders a right of first refusal to buy new shares in the company), pre-emptive rights will typically take precedence. It is therefore essential to address this issue to enable the majority shareholder to negotiate with potential buyers without being constrained by pre-emptive rights.
Share Price
Minority shareholders in a strong negotiating position may require a guaranteed minimum price to avoid being compelled to sell at an undervalued rate, particularly in scenarios where the majority shareholder seeks a quick sale. Additionally, minority shareholders may seek assurances that the price offered for their shares reflects a fair valuation.
Representations and Warranties
Typically, minority shareholders subject to drag-along rights are not expected to give representations and warranties beyond those concerning capacity and title. This is due to their lack of influence over the warranty package agreed upon by the selling majority shareholder in the sale documentation.
Forms of Consideration
Drag-along rights are usually drafted with the assumption that the purchaser will offer cash consideration.
Minority shareholders are likely to contest any drag-along rights that would apply to the sale of their shares for anything other than for cash, for example, a share for a share exchange, which could result in them holding a minority stake in another company with limited rights and no exit route. For this reason, minority shareholders may insist that the drag-along rights contain a stipulation that the consideration for their shares must be paid in cash.
When are Drag-Along Rights Activated?
Drag-along rights will usually be triggered in all types of sales transactions, such as:
- a merger
- the sale of substantial assets of the company
- a sale of company securities
- an acquisition
To initiate a drag-along sale, a minimum ownership percentage of 51% is required for voting purposes. However, the specific ownership percentage necessary to trigger the sale may differ based on the ownership structure and the negotiating power of the shareholders.
Notice Required To Invoke Drag-Along Rights
To exercise drag-along rights, the majority shareholder must provide formal notification to minority shareholders. The notice should include pertinent details of the sale or transaction, such as the identity of the third-party buyer and the transaction timeline.
Restrictions Imposed By Minority Shareholders
Sometimes, minority owners may put restrictions in place that could delay or block a drag-along sale from happening. They may demand a guaranteed minimum price or return over a designated time before the drag-along right can be enforced or they may require the board of directors to approve the sale to ensure that the sale reflects a fair market value.
Can Drag-Along Rights Provide Advantages To Minority Shareholders?
While drag-along rights primarily benefit majority shareholders, they can also offer significant advantages for minority shareholders.
This type of provision provides that the price, terms and conditions of a share sale be uniformly applied to minority shareholders, just as they do any other seller. Consequently, minority shareholders may be able to secure more favourable sales terms than they would typically be able to negotiate given their lack of influence.
Drag-along rights provisions usually stipulate that minority shareholders receive advance notice regarding any corporate action and the associated terms of any sale. Failure to adhere to these procedures may render the drag-along rights ineffective.
Tag-Along Rights
Tag-along rights, also known as ‘co-sale rights,’ are contractual provisions that allow minority shareholders to participate in the sale of a company’s shares at the same time and for the same price for the shares as the majority shareholder.
These rights serve as a safeguard for minority shareholders in situations where a majority shareholder decides to sell their shares in a company, allowing them to join or ‘tag along’ with the transaction and exit on the same terms. Without tag-along rights, minority shareholders may find themselves at a disadvantage, potentially left without a viable exit strategy if the majority shareholder sells its shares to an external investor.
Generally, the provisions for tag-along rights are structured to specify that any failure to adhere to the established tag-along procedures will render any attempt to purchase shares in the company invalid.
Tag-Along Rights – The Advantages and Disadvantages
Tag-along rights present both benefits and drawbacks. While they serve as a protective measure for minority shareholders, they also come with certain limitations.
Advantages
A primary benefit of tag-along rights is that it protects minority shareholders from being excluded when the majority shareholder opts to sell its shares to an unknown third-party investor. In such situations, minority shareholders often lack the leverage to negotiate favourable terms. Tag-along rights empower these minority shareholders by allowing them to sell their shares on the same or comparable terms as the majority shareholders.
For majority shareholders, tag-along rights improve the liquidity of the company, potentially making it more appealing to prospective buyers interested in acquiring a larger controlling interest in the business.
Additionally, these rights help mitigate the likelihood of conflict and dispute in the event of a sale, thereby reducing the risk of minority shareholders pursuing legal action over unfair treatment in a sale.
Furthermore, tag-along rights promote transparency in business operations and foster trust among shareholders, as minority shareholders are assured that they cannot be easily sidelined.
Disadvantages
Conversely, a significant disadvantage of tag-along rights is that they may deter potential buyers since the involvement of multiple minority shareholders exercising their tag-along rights could inflate the overall purchase price for the buyer. Moreover, the necessity of obtaining consent from all tag-along shareholders can prolong the sale process, further discouraging potential buyers.
Additionally, tag-along rights may discourage majority shareholders from investing as they are compelled to consider the interests of the minority shareholders alongside their own.
Considerations For Negotiating Tag-Along Rights
Similarly to drag-along right provisions, tag-along provisions must be explicitly articulated and clearly defined. Some of the factors that should be taken into account when negotiating tag-along rights include:
Scope of Shares Sale
It is essential to determine the extent of the tag-along rights - specifically whether they should be activated only when the majority opts to sell all their shares or if a partial sale would also trigger these rights.
Notice, Timing and Execution
Negotiations regarding tag-along rights should establish the notification period and timing for exercising a tag-along right, ensuring that minority shareholders have adequate time to prepare for the potential sale. You will also need to outline how the sale will be executed and how the terms of the sale will be enforced.
Representations and Warranties
Another critical aspect of the negotiation is whether minority shareholders exercising their tag-along rights should provide the same representations and warranties as the majority shareholders or whether they should only provide a more limited set. There is a compelling argument for requiring the same warranties, especially because it is the minority shareholders who initiate the exercise of their tag-along rights.
Comparison of Drag-Along Rights and Tag-Along Rights
Tag-along rights and drag-along rights protect the interests of different groups of shareholders when a company is sold. Tag-along rights protect minority shareholders by allowing them to participate in a sale initiated by the majority shareholder, permitting them to sell their shares at the same price and terms. Meanwhile, drag-along rights favour majority shareholders. If a majority shareholder decides to sell their shares, they can exercise drag-along rights to force a minority shareholder to also sell their shares to the same buyer. This allows them to ensure that they can deliver 100% of the company shares to a buyer.
Drag-along and tag-along rights are essential mechanisms in shareholders’ agreements, which together, balance the interests of the majority and minority shareholders, promoting fairness and stability in corporate transactions.
Where Are Drag-Along and Tag-Along Rights Typically Found?
Drag-along and tag-along rights are typically incorporated within a company’s articles of association and/or shareholder’s agreement. Additionally, tag-along rights may be included in share offerings as well as merger and acquisition agreements.
How We Can Assist
There is considerable scope for negotiating the scope and specifics of drag-along and tag-along rights. With our extensive experience working with both majority and minority shareholders, we are well-equipped to guide all legal aspects of contractual arrangements between company shareholders. We will ensure that you have the right clauses in place that are tailored to the specific needs of the company and your position as a shareholder so that you are protected as best as possible.
For more information on how our expert corporate law solicitors can help you, contact us on 0330 173 3980 or email us.
FAQ
How do tag-along rights differ from pre-emptive rights?
Minority shareholders may also have pre-emptive rights in addition to tag-along rights. Pre-emptive rights allow current shareholders the first opportunity to purchase additional shares before they are offered to new investors, thereby enabling them to maintain their proportional ownership in the company.
Tag-along rights concentrate on the sale of shares, whereas pre-emptive shares rights are structured to safeguard existing shareholders from dilution.
What advantages do appraisal rights provide to minority shareholders?
Appraisal rights provide minority shareholders with the entitlement to seek a fair valuation and compensation for their shares if they oppose certain corporate actions, such as mergers or consolidations.
This mechanism serves as a protective measure, ensuring that minority shareholders receive fair treatment and are not compelled to accept unfavourable terms.
What is the purpose of shareholder information rights?
Shareholder information rights are crucial as they grant shareholders access to vital company data, including financial statements, annual reports and board meeting minutes. This access enhances transparency, enabling shareholders to make well-informed decisions about their investments, monitor company performance and hold management accountable for their actions.
Image by KamranAydinov on Freepik
